A Rejoinder to Mack Stiles’ criticism of InterVarsity at 9Marks

While 9Marks is not a mainstream evangelical byword, it is read by an influential segment of reformed people. The recent article published there by Mack Stiles threw me when I ran across it. In that article he expressed deep concern that InterVarsity was stepping over a line theologically that is moving them away from evangelicalism.

The blog Euangelion offers a balanced and thoughtful response that seems at first read to adequately address the issues Stiles raises.

My home territory is reformed theology, but I have always felt uneasy around the attempt on the part of many in that camp to make their understanding of the gospel –  complete with election, predestination, double imputation and substitutionary atonement, etc.,  – the only possible version of the Good News. So that all other versions are in fact no gospel.

While this certainly is true with respect to the rationalistic, miracle denying, progressive versions of the gospel offered to us from the liberal camp, we must be very careful lest we shrink the gospel down so far that no one is preaching the gospel but the reformed.

Do I agree with Mack Stiles on the understanding of the gospel he believes and preaches? Essentially yes. But I can sign the Evangelicals and Catholics Together statements. Chuck Colsom and JI Packer signed it and they are  full-fledged gospelers. I can read NT Wright and still believe he is within the camp, as much as I can believe the Puritan Richard Hooker was within the camp.

I am sure that Mack Stiles’ article received some applause from the circle of those who read 9 Marks. But it will fall on deaf ears on the larger Christian community, like RC Sproul’s attempt to take Chuck Colson to the woodshed.

4 thoughts on “A Rejoinder to Mack Stiles’ criticism of InterVarsity at 9Marks

  1. i would not have figured this had been interesting a number years back nevertheless it’s amusing the way in which years alters the manner in which you perceive abnormal concepts, thanks regarding the article it is relaxing to browse some thing smart once in a while instead of the ordinary crap mascarading as blogs on the internet, i’m going to have fun with a few rounds of zynga poker, adios for now

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s